TL;DR
Get coffee and tea gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai tested a dozen frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week to find a stand-in for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. She picked Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese, reporting that it cost $8 for four sandwiches, compared with $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich at the time of her test.
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai has named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese her closest frozen substitute for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin after tasting 12 sandwiches from five brands over a week. In her report, the Jimmy Dean pack cost $8 for four sandwiches, while the McDonald’s sandwich she bought cost $4.89, making the taste test relevant to shoppers looking for a less expensive at-home option.
Domrongchai said the two sandwiches share the main components: an English muffin, egg, cheese and sausage. She described the Jimmy Dean version as similar in appearance and said its sausage was juicy, its egg soft after reheating, and its cheddar cheese gooey and sharp. She also found it less greasy than the McDonald’s sandwich, without feeling it gave up flavor.
The products are not identical. According to Domrongchai, Jimmy Dean’s sausage includes chicken, while McDonald’s sandwich uses a whole egg with a firm yolk. The Jimmy Dean sandwich has a scrambled egg patty. Those differences may matter to shoppers who prefer the texture or ingredients of the fast-food version.
The price comparison in the report was $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches, or $2 per sandwich based on the pack price, versus $4.89 for one Egg McMuffin. Domrongchai also listed a McDonald’s meal with a hash brown and coffee at $7.29. The report says prices were accurate when published; it does not establish current prices across locations or retailers.
A Lower-Cost Breakfast at Home
The comparison offers shoppers a practical alternative to buying a prepared breakfast sandwich on each trip. Based on the prices Domrongchai encountered, the Jimmy Dean multipack cost less than half as much per sandwich as the McDonald’s item. Frozen sandwiches can also be kept at home and reheated, avoiding a separate restaurant stop when time is limited.
That cost and convenience comparison is specific to one editor’s test, one product pack and the prices she found. It is not a controlled nutrition or value study, and individual taste preferences may differ. The review’s useful takeaway is narrower: among the 12 products she tried, she preferred this Jimmy Dean sandwich as a close match for the Egg McMuffin.
Jimmy Dean English Muffin Egg and Cheese frozen breakfast sandwiches
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sandwich Test Worked
Domrongchai framed the test around her preference for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin and her reluctance to pay the price she encountered for it. She ate a dozen frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands during the week, seeking a freezer option with a similar combination of egg, sausage, cheese and English muffin. The published report identifies Jimmy Dean as the winner but does not provide a full ranked list or detailed scores for all 12 sandwiches.
The Kitchn noted a previous comparison by contributor Kate, who had selected a Jimmy Dean sausage, egg and cheese biscuit as a match for a McDonald’s biscuit. That earlier review is separate from Domrongchai’s test, which focused on finding a substitute for the English muffin-based Egg McMuffin. The article also states that The Kitchn independently selects products and may earn a commission if readers buy through its links.
““Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese was the closest to my favorite McDonald’s one.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn associate editor
Prices and Preferences May Vary
The report does not say whether the cited prices are still available, or how they compare across regions, stores or promotions. It also does not provide nutrition information, a full breakdown of the other brands tested, standardized cooking conditions, or blind-taste-test results. The finding that Jimmy Dean was the closest match is Domrongchai’s personal judgment, not a universal ranking or proof that every shopper will prefer it.
The source does not give a detailed account of how the sandwiches were reheated or report a food-safety assessment. Buyers should follow the package’s storage and heating directions. The report also does not compare the total cost of preparing the frozen sandwich at home with the price of a McDonald’s meal beyond the listed item prices.
What Shoppers Can Check
The article describes a completed taste test and names its preferred option; it does not announce a follow-up review or a new product launch. Readers considering the sandwiches can check current prices and package sizes at their local stores, then compare ingredients and serving information with their own preferences. Reheating should follow the instructions printed on the product packaging.
Any broader takeaway will depend on how the products taste to other people and what they cost where they shop. The test provides a specific recommendation from one editor, while current local pricing and the remaining products’ rankings are not supplied in the report.
Key Questions
Which frozen sandwich did The Kitchn editor prefer?
Ali Domrongchai named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese the closest match to McDonald’s Egg McMuffin among the 12 sandwiches she tried.
How did the prices compare in the review?
Domrongchai reported paying $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches and $4.89 for one McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. These were the prices at the time of her test and may have changed.
Are the Jimmy Dean and McDonald’s sandwiches identical?
No. The review says the Jimmy Dean version has a scrambled egg patty and sausage that includes chicken; the McDonald’s sandwich has a whole egg with a firm yolk. Both include an English muffin, cheese and sausage.
Was the comparison a blind or scientific test?
The source describes a weeklong personal taste test of 12 sandwiches from five brands. It does not say the tasting was blind or provide a formal scoring method, so the result should be read as the editor’s preference.
Source: rss
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
